Just bring a flashlight if it is dark, stay aware of passing traffic on US-31, and keep the stop simple. Quiet suits this place remarkably well.
Look At The Stonework Before You Fill …

The structure itself deserves a moment before you reach for a cap or handle. Its stonework gives the well a grounded, handmade presence, as if the site were shaped less by branding than by local use and long memory.
Even weathering becomes part of the story. This is not polished heritage interpretation. It is practical architecture with dignity.
That matters because the well has been known for generations, with local memories reaching back at least to the mid twentieth century. You can sense that continuity in the masonry and the simple roadside arrangement.
Take a quick look, then fill efficiently. Lingering is fine, but this is one of those places where appreciation is best expressed through gentle, unobtrusive behavior.