Appreciation and caution can comfortably coexist. It also helps to separate this well from discussion of Alanson municipal tap water, which is a different supply altogether. The artesian well’s reputation stands on its own.
When you fill up, use clean containers and your own judgment about how you plan to drink or store the water once you get it home.
Go At Off Hours If You Like Quiet …

Because the well is accessible 24 hours a day, timing can change the mood completely. A midday stop may feel social and brisk, with cars rotating through the pull-off, while an early morning or late evening visit can feel almost meditative, all cold air, road noise, and the bright sound of water hitting plastic.
The place rewards people who do not mind unconventional timing. I found that useful if the goal was efficiency rather than conversation. Off hours also make it easier to maneuver containers without feeling hurried.