My kids read those letters privately. Caleb kept his. Terrence put his away in a drawer and never mentioned it again. Malcolm said he needed time. Simone cried for an hour. Natalie filed hers away as part of the family’s history, like evidence of something she’d never stop writing about.
None of them owed Eleanor forgiveness. None of them were wrong for feeling whatever they felt.
A year after that first big birthday party, my kids threw me another one — this time at my own house. No decorations from a florist, no speeches, no reporters. Just food, music, and the sound of five siblings giving each other grief around a kitchen table.
Caleb brought dessert. Terrence brought flowers. Malcolm fixed the porch light I’d been complaining about for months. Simone helped cook. And Natalie brought a framed photo — the one taken at my sixtieth birthday, right before Nathan walked in. Me in the middle, all five of my kids around me, all of us smiling like nothing in the world could touch us.