Inside the box were a pair of enormous trousers Edward had worn when he was much heavier. He explained that he had once struggled with body image and felt undeserving of happiness because of his weight. He then revealed that the narrator had helped him through that difficult period by treating him with kindness and never making him feel broken. His heartfelt words silenced the guests and left Max embarrassed. The narrator realized that Edward remembered her as someone compassionate, even when she had struggled to recognize those qualities in herself.
Later, Edward explained that his gift was not simply intended to embarrass Max. He wanted her to understand that she had spent too much time trying to prove she was worthy of love to the man who had hurt her. She did not owe Max any proof of her value. Before she could respond, her youngest daughter asked why she had pretended Edward was her boyfriend. The narrator honestly admitted she wanted her father to believe someone still wanted her.