At dawn, I left Penelope with Avis, then followed Gwen to her car.
“Should I be worried?” I asked.
“Malcolm should,” Gwen replied dryly. “Your face is terrible at hiding reactions, so don’t ask questions yet.”
We pulled onto Malcolm’s street while the houses were still dark. Gwen opened the trunk—it was packed full.
“What is all this?” I asked.
“Things I should have returned years ago.”
She handed me the first cardboard box. We carried everything to Malcolm’s porch: baseball trophies, photo albums, college boxes, winter clothes, and a battered guitar he hadn’t touched in years.
Gwen arranged them in a neat row and laid a handwritten note on top: YOU WANTED YOUR OWN LIFE. HERE IT IS.
“This is your brilliant plan?” I whispered.
“First part,” Gwen said. “Much more to come. Now we wait quietly.”
We parked around the corner. Twenty minutes later, his front door opened. He stepped outside, stopped, then shouted loudly enough to wake half the block: “Oh my God! Who did this?”