Mr. Hartwell’s face became very serious. “James Brooks?”
“Yeah. He died before I was born. That’s what my dad told me.”
The attorney was silent for a moment. A car went by on Hamilton Cleves Road. Somewhere in the restaurant kitchen, somebody dropped a pan.
“Nathan,” he said, “James Brooks was alive until a few weeks ago.”
My knees went weak. I put my hand on the side of the dumpster to hold myself up. “No,” I said. “That’s impossible.”
“He spent years trying to find out whether he had a grandson,” Mr. Hartwell said. “Six months ago, he finally found proof that you existed. He hired a private investigator. The investigator found your birth certificate in Butler County and a school photograph from the Hamilton High yearbook.” He paused. “I wish to God we’d found you sooner.”
He opened his briefcase on the hood of my dead car and took out a photograph. An old man stood in front of a big brick house with white trim and a wide front porch, smiling gently at the camera. He had white hair and a cardigan sweater and a cane. The resemblance to my father was unmistakable. The same jaw. The same nose. The same deep line between the eyebrows.