THE JUDGE
She spoke for about four minutes.
I will not give you all of it. She said it plainly, to nobody in particular, with her hands folded, in the voice of a woman who has long ago stopped being surprised and has never quite got used to it.
She said that the petition was denied. She said that the court found, on the evidence of the minor child, which it found entirely credible, that the petitioner had sought the termination of the guardianship not in the best interests of the child, but for a collateral purpose that he had taken steps to conceal. She said that she did not doubt that his motive was one of great love, and of fear, and that she had a son of her own, once, who had been ill. She said that this did not excuse it.
“The law,” said Judge Hartley, “has always had a place for a father who comes to a court and says, my child is dying, and I need help. It has a place for a father who goes to a grandmother, on his knees, and asks. It has no place at all for a man who decides that a woman of seventy-five and a girl of eleven are, I believe the phrase was, a bit of blood.”