“Absolutely.”
Natalie turned another page.
“But he didn’t take your wages as rent.”
“And he expected you to save?”
Ben shifted in his chair.
“That was different.”
“How?”
“I was working for him.”
“Exactly, Dad.”
“That was different.”
She pointed toward the ledger.
“He taught you to earn money.”
“Yes.”
“And helped you keep some.”
Ben looked down.
“He taught you to earn money.”
I recognized the photograph.
Walter had framed it after Ben’s graduation.
Ben had told us that story dozens of times.
But there was another part.
One I’d almost forgotten.
I recognized the photograph.
Walter had helped Ben save for his first apartment.
Not by handing him everything.
By making sure he had somewhere to begin.
***
Natalie touched the envelope.
“Why was that good parenting for Grandpa?”
He had somewhere to begin.
She waited.
“And bad parenting for you?”
Ben leaned back.
“Times have changed, Natalie.”
“I know, Dad.”