I pulled out a neatly folded stack of printed order confirmations and handed the first page to Karen.
“Recognize this?”
She glanced at it.
Her face went pale.
“What… where did you get that?”
I recognized them immediately.
“From our online bakery, of course!”
I turned toward the curious parents.
“You see, Lily and I run a small baking business. She makes all the desserts, and I handle the orders and payments.”
Karen opened her mouth, but I continued.
I pointed at the customer’s name.
“When Madison unpacked her treats earlier, I recognized them immediately. I actually helped Lily pack that order last Thursday.”
I unfolded another page.
“Twelve vampire cookies, eight purple ghosts, twenty pumpkin cupcakes. All the same designs and quantities displayed on Madison’s table.”
I pointed at the customer’s name.
I unfolded another page.
“And look! Karen, what a coincidence! You’re our mystery customer!”
Someone behind me gasped.